Anyways Naoto Shirogane Is Transgender Because He Was Willing To Let His Shadow Magically Change His

Anyways Naoto Shirogane is transgender because he was willing to let his shadow magically change his sex

Naoto Shirogane is transgender because his story focuses heavily on gender dysphoria

Naoto Shirogane is transgender because he openly expressed his desire to be born as a man.

Naoto Shirogane is transgender because his shadow deals with internalized transphobia and once he voices his self doubt (his shadow calling himself "really a girl") no one in the group respects Naoto's preferred pronouns, immediately switching to she/her, and never give him a chance to truly explain himself, instead opting to push him to "accept that he's a woman"

Naoto Shirogane was afraid of being seen as a child and (because of his dysphoria) as a girl, and him being treated with misdirected misogyny in the past does not mean he was really a girl all along. He went through great lengths to be seen as a boy (more than a cis woman ever would, especially to the point of extremely dangerous chest binding), and if he still wasn't taken seriously it was because he was and is a child (15)

Naoto's romance route is disgusting as to unlock it you must push your views for him to be a woman on him when he is expressing his doubts about his identity.

Things like this do NOT happen on accident. ATLUS knew what they were doing.

Atlus is complicit with the transphobic narrative of Naoto Shirogane. It doesnt matter if they were TRYING to address misogyny in Japanese workplaces what they actually DID was write a trans man who is forced to ignore his true feelings for the comfort of everyone else around him, and imply that trans men are really just struggling with internalized misogyny and that is extremely transphobic.

I am under no obligation to accept canon in my own fan works or in my own fandom space. Im under no obligation to interact with people who DO.

The Naoto post i made a month ago now serves as a giant blocklist for me and every other transmasc persona4 fan.

If you can't handle a trans headcanon you don't need to interact with me. Block me and move on like an adult.

DO NOT INTERACT OR ARGUE WITH ME OR THIS POST IF YOU CALL NAOTO A WOMAN. THIS IS NOT AN INVITATION. I GENUINELY HATE YOU AND DON'T WANT TO DEAL WITH YOUR CIS/BOOTLICKING NONSENSE.

More Posts from Moonybondevik and Others

1 year ago

Hey! šŸ’™

🪐 DID system of +100

🌐 ESP / ENG

āš˜ļø We use our principal blog for fandom and polytheism stuff mostly

ā­ļø Our factives blog here: @starlinefactives

šŸŒ… Our fictives blog here: @sunrisefictives

We're open to talk but our anxiety makes hard to keep in check of chats. we're working on that! šŸ’™

Matantei Loki Ragnarok. Gif
Loki closes a book

Tags
2 years ago
Lost Innocence.

Lost innocence.

5 years ago
It’s Never Enough

It’s never enough

1 month ago

Me everytime someone gives me a weird look when i say that black butler is my fav manga

moonybondevik - Angel
5 years ago

I'm back

Nadie me echaba de menos pero por avisar que ya no soy la misma persona de antes, han padado cuatro años y miedo me da cómo podía ser antes

SaludosšŸ‘€

I'm Back

Tags
2 years ago

This issue made me to angry to sleep so many nights... i feel the same

I’m Tired and Angry, here’s some Anime character gender discourse

Not to get into anime gender discourse, but arguing about an anime character’s gender, like Chihiro from Danganronpa or Naoto from Persona, is entirely pointless considering the people who wrote them clearly didn’t, and probably don’t, acknowledge trans people at all, like, in general. Its very clear why the confusion of how to interpret their gender comes up, as the stories resonate very heavily with some trans people, but are ultimately denied representation because the writers just didn’t give enough of a shit to think of transgender people while creating a plotline explicitly about one’s connection with their gender, and instead of actually going somewhere constructive and giving good representation, boomerang right intoĀ ā€œThey actually fuckin’ love being their AGAB, and all of that questioning and shit was pointless, maybe at most meant to have a message about sexism or some shit.ā€ And especially in the case of Naoto, its very clear that he’s a trans man, to the point where up until the game makes it very clear he’s a cis woman you have to actively try to think he’s not trangender (Like, his shadow’s whole fucking deal was to physically change his own body so he could be a cis man, its literally right there.) Oh course, the writers then decide to go down a painfully familiarĀ ā€œOh, no, its just because the workforce they wish to be apart of is sexist towards women and no other reason for them to have issues with their gender!ā€ (See, how people describe people like James Barry) which is just a very regressive view on this matter. So like, it gets stuck at this point where canonically, these characters are cis but are written very much as transgender, and while headcanons are great and all, Naoto will only ever be acknowledged as a cis woman, Chihiro will only ever be considered a cis man, and the writers behind them never have to or want to even think about the implications of these characters and how much it just hurts to not be represented in characters who could be very good pieces of representation if the writers gave half of a rat’s shit about transgender people.

In short: Media written about implicatively transgender characters will always suck when written by people who don’t care about transgender people and any discourse about what gender they are is null and void because of this.

I’m sure tons of people have made this exact take but its 4 am and I’m too angry to sleep.

9 years ago

SĆ­.... Por favor.... TT^TT)

Bad luck

A quien no les gustaria escuchar mĆ”s canciones de bad luck? (nuevas) por que por mi … seria genail…


Tags
4 years ago

this is so real...

Just saying... (TRIGGER WARNING AND SPOILERS)

Just Saying... (TRIGGER WARNING AND SPOILERS)
Just Saying... (TRIGGER WARNING AND SPOILERS)

Killing off characters that have struggled with trauma and abuse before getting their redemption gives a really bad message to people who struggle with depression and PTSD.

7 months ago
Look Who’s Getting Ready For Halloween !

Look who’s getting ready for Halloween !

Look Who’s Getting Ready For Halloween !

Also bonus sketch of the finished jack-o lanterns

(Sebaciels dni )

  • part-3
    part-3 reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • redplantmichael
    redplantmichael liked this · 1 year ago
  • consideringthehairpinturn
    consideringthehairpinturn liked this · 1 year ago
  • littlelapin
    littlelapin liked this · 1 year ago
  • oliveratemptsstuff
    oliveratemptsstuff liked this · 2 years ago
  • grimmtheend
    grimmtheend reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • endingboyhansel
    endingboyhansel liked this · 2 years ago
  • moonybondevik
    moonybondevik reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • moonybondevik
    moonybondevik liked this · 2 years ago
  • gdgdfairiess
    gdgdfairiess liked this · 3 years ago
  • tricky-bad-luck-queen
    tricky-bad-luck-queen liked this · 3 years ago
  • acedefectiveprince
    acedefectiveprince liked this · 3 years ago
  • roseolaf
    roseolaf liked this · 3 years ago
  • min-park-420
    min-park-420 reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • changelinghearts
    changelinghearts liked this · 3 years ago
  • atikal
    atikal liked this · 3 years ago
  • bakedgud
    bakedgud reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • vampmachina
    vampmachina reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • arkaynist
    arkaynist liked this · 4 years ago
  • itsmeyakid
    itsmeyakid liked this · 4 years ago
  • bonniehop
    bonniehop liked this · 4 years ago
  • kitsune-kira
    kitsune-kira liked this · 4 years ago
  • pinkwesker
    pinkwesker liked this · 4 years ago
  • billiumweasle
    billiumweasle liked this · 4 years ago
  • danidoesathing
    danidoesathing reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • danidoesathing
    danidoesathing liked this · 4 years ago
  • honestlybabyitscool
    honestlybabyitscool liked this · 4 years ago
  • sunnysknife
    sunnysknife reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • sunnysknife
    sunnysknife liked this · 4 years ago
  • s-uwu-cide
    s-uwu-cide liked this · 4 years ago
  • kamiko
    kamiko liked this · 4 years ago
  • pullthewildcard
    pullthewildcard liked this · 4 years ago
  • smtnine
    smtnine liked this · 4 years ago
  • juiced-box
    juiced-box reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • juiced-box
    juiced-box liked this · 4 years ago
  • yoshikass
    yoshikass liked this · 4 years ago
  • idontknowwhatnametoputin
    idontknowwhatnametoputin liked this · 4 years ago
  • ochaka-archive
    ochaka-archive liked this · 4 years ago
  • oukawacore
    oukawacore reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • mikejimacore
    mikejimacore reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • dweeby-the-demon
    dweeby-the-demon liked this · 4 years ago

ā˜†ā˜… DID system | LGBTAQ+ ā˜…ā˜†Norse mythology | Multifandom | ENG / ESP

84 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags