Ok 3:00 Am Theory Time

Ok 3:00 am Theory time

In the QSMP trailer towards the end we hear Charlie and Quackity talking to each other on the train to the island. I don’t know if this was purposeful or accidental but Charlie and Quackity are not on the same train. Charlie is on the Left Train while Quackity is on the Right Train. If it was purposeful maybe that conversation that you hear was from before they got on the train? If not then maybe Charlie, as a slime can split himself in different part and a small bit was with Quackity idk.

Moving on we then hear Wilbur talking to someone where he says “ I just don’t get it. Why are they putting us in different trains?”

At first I thought he was talking about how they separated the guests into two different trains to the island instead of one. But I had a thought that maybe they separated the group he was traveling with.

Foolish and BBH have both stated that they have memories of the DSMP. Whether that was a past life or memories from that time have been removed we don’t know.

Taking this info we can hypothesize that maybe Quackity and Wilbur were traveling together to this island and Wilbur, in the previously stated convo, was talking about why they separated two people who were traveling together?

Cool. Now who is Wilbur talking to?

Well as both him and Philza were on the same train the probability of Philza being the second person makes sense. Especially if we go with the thought that DSMP is something that actually happened in the past.

Now onto recent lore as of posting this.

In the crime as to why the Islanders are arrested by the federation Philza is marked as having “Trespassing and Illegal dimension crossing”

From what I’ve seen only three other people have this crime Foolish, BBH, and Fitmc. Now we know why Fit has that crime. He was not on the original guest list, someone got him a a ticket so he can go in as a spy to report back info from the inside.

Going off this info does this mean that Foolish, BBH, and Philza were not originally on the guest list? Did Phil come to the island to do something or did he come to make sure Wilbur was ok? Why do Foolish and BBH, who are both immortals if I may note, also have that crime?

Idk it’s 3:00am, I’m going to bed.

-Crimes are on QSMPinfo twitter

-BBH and foolish convos of dsmp are on their wikis

-Who was on what train is also on the wiki

Here’s the trailer

https://x.com/Quackity/status/1636854517693288450?s=20

If I missed anything or made a mistake plz let me know and In the end this is just a crazy theory